We raise the taste level.

Reddit

We raise the taste level.

Reddit

/

Marketing

/

Competition is mimicry

Competition is mimicry

René Girard argued that human desire is not original. We don’t want things because of their intrinsic value; we want them because we watch other people want them first. Desire is borrowed, copied, transmitted between people like a contagion. Girard called this mimetic desire, and he believed it was the engine behind most human conflict. When everyone imitates the same desire, everyone ends up fighting over the same object and idea.

Peter Thiel took this idea and pointed it at business. In Zero to One, he argued that competition is for losers, not as a provocation, but as a literal description of when companies imitate each other instead of building something genuinely their own. Competitors converge on the same customers, the same features, and the same language; this might work for small local businesses in rural areas, but in large cities and megalopolises, nobody is differentiated, and everybody is exhausted. The only way out, Thiel says, is to build a monopoly: something so specific and hard to copy that competition stops being relevant.

When we put those two ideas together, we get a precise diagnosis of what’s wrong with most marketing today. Companies don’t write “innovative,” “trusted,” and “premium quality” because those words are true. They write them out of mimicry because competitors are already saying them, and it feels riskier to say nothing or to say something different that sounds like the opposite. It’s mimicry, applied to language. And like all mimicry, it produces convergence, a market where every company sounds like every other company.

This gives us two domains that almost all commercial language falls into.


Mimetic Language and Monopoly Language

Mimetic language is abstract words borrowed from what everyone else is already saying. It doesn’t describe what a company actually did; it describes what a company wants to be seen and sound like, using vocabulary lifted from competitors, culture, and category convention. It’s cheap to produce, safe to publish, and, for that exact reason, forgettable.

Monopoly language is the opposite: language that reports something real, specific, and structurally hard for anyone else to say. It doesn’t borrow desire; it earns it by naming something the company actually built, decided, or proved before a single sentence was written.

The split isn’t about tone, or length, or cleverness. It’s about whether the sentence is reporting evidence or just wearing the costume of confidence.

Mimetic Language: the three axes

Mimetic language still needs to sound relevant, which means it isn’t random; it clusters around three axes, each answering a different silent question in the reader’s mind.

Axis

Silent question

Typical vocabulary

What it signals

Field

"Do you know what you're doing?"

seamless, crafted, clinically proven, secure

competence, category membership

Identity

"Who does this make me?"

empowering, bold, for the makers, you deserve

borrowed self-image

Availability

"Is this for everyone, or for me specifically?"

exclusive, limited, affordable, for everyone

status vs. belonging

Any brand can reach into these three jars. A fintech app says “secure” (field) because every fintech app has to, not because it proves anything. A skincare brand says “you deserve this” (identity) because that sentence has already been said, successfully, by a hundred other skincare brands. A SaaS company says “exclusive early access” (availability) with no actual cap on signups, borrowing the feeling of scarcity without the reality of it.

This is not dishonest, but a camouflage, the linguistic minimum required to look like a legitimate player in a category, without doing the work of being one. The tell is simple: swap the logo, and the sentence still works. That’s what mimicry sounds like.

Monopoly Language: the three rules

Monopoly language passes a harder test, one that can be checked sentence by sentence.

Rule

Question

What it filters out

Visualize

Can I picture this before I decide if I believe it?

abstract nouns with nothing to render

Falsify

Could this, in principle, be proven wrong?

vague claims that protect the brand by meaning nothing

Ownable

Could a direct competitor say this exact sentence and have it also be true?

anything borrowed from the shared category vocabulary

“You get fresh pizza in 30 minutes, or it’s free” passes all three: you can picture the clock, it’s checkable, and it requires a company to actually build the delivery logistics to say it. “Melts in your mouth, not in your hands” only works for one company, because it’s not a mood, it’s a fact about a specific manufacturing process. Compare that to “premium quality without the premium price tag”, visualisable in only the vaguest way, unfalsifiable, and copy-pasteable onto any product on earth.

The three rules aren’t really three separate checks. They’re one chain: visualising forces specificity, specificity makes a claim checkable, and a claim checkable against your own actual operations is, almost by definition, not true of a competitor who never did that operation. Ownability isn’t a writing skill. It’s what happens automatically once a company has done something real enough to report.


Why is this a market problem, not a writing problem?

There’s one honest exception to all of this: legacy: A company that’s existed for thirty or forty years, or spent tens of millions of dollars repeating the same line, can make mimetic language work through sheer volume; Nike’s “Just Do It” is abstract, but it’s been paired with Bannister, Jordan, and decades of concrete imagery until the abstraction became a container people fill in automatically. That’s not really the sentence working. That’s the marketing budget working, disguised as the sentence.

Almost no company today has that luxury. Post-COVID, margins are thinner, acquisition costs are higher, and capital is less patient, which means most companies can’t afford to spend a decade letting an abstract slogan earn its meaning through repetition. And this is exactly where Thiel’s argument closes the loop: competition is for losers because competitors who imitate each other are, by definition, fighting over the same shrinking attention with the same borrowed words and ideas. A company using mimetic language isn’t just being unoriginal; it’s choosing to compete in the one arena where it has no structural advantage: sounding like everyone else, in a market with less room every year to be forgettable.

This is also why we now watch brands rise and disappear within weeks. Social media doesn’t just spread hype faster; it strips away the one thing that used to let mimetic language survive: time. A legacy brand could take a decade to let an abstract slogan accumulate meaning through repetition. A brand born on social media gets a two-week window of attention, and if nothing underneath the hype is specific, checkable, or singular, there’s nothing left to remember once the algorithm moves on. The hype cycle doesn’t kill these brands; it just removes the cover that used to hide the fact that they never said anything ownable in the first place. Fame at that speed isn’t proof of differentiation; it’s often proof that nobody looked closely enough, for long enough, to notice there was nothing underneath.

The companies that survive this environment won’t be the ones with the cleverest copywriting. They’ll be the ones that did something specific enough to be visualised, checkable enough to be falsified, and singular enough that no competitor could copy-paste the idea or the sentence and have it stay true. Everyone else is just adding their name to a slogan someone else already wrote, and, increasingly, being forgotten at the same speed they were discovered.

We raise the taste level.

A creative director who lives at the intersection of art, strategy, and chaos.
Redefine what’s possible, to reach the source, to push boundaries, with Free design tools built by a creative director: image resizer, colour palette and more...

Copyright © 2026.All Right reserved.

We raise the taste level.

We raise the taste level.

A creative director who lives at the intersection of art, strategy, and chaos.
Redefine what’s possible, to reach the source, to push boundaries, with Free design tools built by a creative director: image resizer, colour palette and more...

Copyright © 2026.All Right reserved.

We raise the taste level.

We raise the taste level.

A creative director who lives at the intersection of art, strategy, and chaos.
Redefine what’s possible, to reach the source, to push boundaries, with Free design tools built by a creative director: image resizer, colour palette and more...

Copyright © 2026.All Right reserved.

We raise the taste level.

Create a free website with Framer, the website builder loved by startups, designers and agencies.